I got the midnight navy, and I love it. Fits good, leaving room to layer without it feeling too baggy. You can adjust how tight it is, though the strap will hang out the side if you do. It's incredibly warm, wearing it out at work in the 20s, and the difference was notable. I would have liked a metal zipper rather than plastic, considering the price. I think that's a fair ask. I noticed some loose threads on the inside, too, an annoying but easy fix. I like the 100% cotton lining. The pattern is nice, and it is soft to the touch.

The usual great Johnson stuff!

I am excited to use this vest. It does run small so take that into account if wearing layers.
I wish they used a metal zipper instead of plastic as that will be the first to go then I will have to find a seamstress to repair it for me. If they use a metal one ( I understand more money) but this vest will last forever.